Skip to content

Universal 170:

Posted in Universals Archive

Universal 170:

Original
If a language has case affixes on nouns, they are almost always suffixed.
Standardized
IF there are case affixes on nouns, THEN they are almost always suffixed.
Keywords
case, noun, affix-order, suffix
Domain
inflection
Type
no genuine implication; rather: provided that
Status
achronic
Quality
statistical
Basis
23-language sample in Sanders 1972; Hawkins & Gilligan surveyed 200 languages drawn from three samples: a 113-language sample of Stassen’s, a 40-language sample of Bybee & Perkins, and a 50-language sample of Gilligan’s; 50-language sample of Maxwell 1979
Source
Wundt 1904: 130; Greenberg 1957: 91; Kuznecov 1960: 30; Sanders 1972: 115 [Sanders 1978: 71]; Kahr 1976: 135-140; Moravcsik 1978: 9; Maxwell 1979: 44; Williams 1981: 251 (crediting K. Hale, p.c.); Donegan & Stampe 1983: 344; Cutler, Hawkins, & Gilligan 1985: 729; Hawkins & Gilligan 1988: 222; McCreight Young 1988: 49; Wandruszka 1992: 4; Moravcsik 1994a: 49
Counterexamples
Classical Armenian (Armenian, IE), Hungarian (Ugric, Uralic) [pronouns] (Baldi 1983);some Semitic and Bantu languages (Moravcsik 1994);Semitic, Cushitic (Afro-Asiatic) (Hetzron 1980: 278);Amharic (Semitic, Afro-Asiatic) (Lehmann 1982: 93);Idoma (Benue-Congo, Niger-Congo) (Reh 1986: 121);Krongo (Kordofanian, Niger-Congo) (Reh 1985: 98);Non-Bari group of Eastern Nilotic (Nilo-Saharan) (Dimmendaal 1987; Heine & Vossen 1983);Zulu (Bantu, Niger-Congo) (Skalicka 1979: 202);Eastern Bushman (Oceanic, Malayo-Polynesian) (Lanham & Hallowes 1956);Australian: Mangarayi (Gunwingguan)(Merlan 1982), Nungali (Djamindjungan) (Hoddinott & Kofod 1976); Mara, Alawa (both Maran), Burarra (Burarran) (see also Blake 1987: 19);Murut (Borneo, Malayo-Polynesian) (Prentice 1981);Huamelultec Chontal (Hokan) (Waterhouse 1967);Squamish (Salish) (Kuipers 1967); Coast Tsimshian? (Tsimshianic) (Dunn 1979);Zapotec (Oto-Manguean), Oaxaca Chontal (Hokan), Squamish (Salish) — none of these languages, however, has case prefixes for subject or object marking, but employs them instead for various locative or adverbial constructions (Hawkins & Gilligan 1988: 222).

One Comment

  1. FP
    FP

    1. This is in essence what is being claimed: Case affixes on nouns tend to be suffixed. There is an implication hidden here, though: If an affix on nouns is a prefix, then it is almost never a case marker. 2. See also #1401 for Sanders’ claim.3. For typologically and diachronically motivated proposals for explaining why case suffixes are common but case prefixes rare, see Kahr 1976, Reh 1986. Generally on the suffixing preference see Hawkins (et al.), Bybee (et al.). An open question for these general accounts is why the suffixing preference is particularly strict for case, certainly stricter than for number. At any rate, there is a diachronic side to the universal, since what is at issue (in all accounts) is how free or clitic relational markers are getting morphologically bound.

    1. May 2020

Comments are closed.