Universal #1156

Legacy number: 1156

 Number  1152
 Original  For any given noun phrase, numerability implies definitizability, and definitizability implies pronominalizability.
 Standardized  For any given noun phrase, IF it is numerable THEN it is definitizable, and IF it is definitizable THEN it is pronominalizable.
 Formula  numerability ⇒ definitizability ⇒ pronominalizability
 Keywords  number, plural, definite, pronoun
 Domain  inflection, syntax
 Type  implication
 Status  achronic
 Quality  absolute
 Basis  106 languages surveyed in Moravcsik 1969
 Source  Moravcsik 1969: 73-74

← Back to Universals Archive

Discussion
Notes
1. In other words, NPs that can be pluralized but not definitized and those that can be pluralized and definitized but not pronominalized are excluded as possible constructions. 2. The claim is that whereas referential marking is not a prerequisite for pronominalization – even generic noun phrases and “predicate nouns“ can be pronominalized – only a subset of pronominalizable things, i. e. those which have reference, can undergo definitization; and (though all nouns with reference are quantifiable) only that subset which is countable can be numerated.
Comment
Frans Plank · 3 Aug 2006
1. In other words, NPs that can be pluralized but not definitized and those that can be pluralized and definitized but not pronominalized are excluded as possible constructions.

2. The claim is that whereas referential marking is not a prerequisite for pronominalization – even generic noun phrases and 'predicate nouns' can be pronominalized – only a subset of pronominalizable things, i. e. those which have reference, can undergo definitization; and (though all nouns with reference are quantifiable) only that subset which is countable can be numerated.