Skip to content

Universal 1103:

Posted in Universals Archive

Universal 1103:

Original
If there is a bound vs. free split, the bound prefixes will be accusative, and case marking on free forms will be ergative.
Standardized
Whenever there is an alignment split between bound and free pronouns, bound (i.e. agreement) forms are more likely to align accusatively, while case marking on free forms is more likely to align ergatively.
Keywords
agreement, alignment, split, case, ergative, accusative
Domain
inflection, syntax
Type
unconditional
Status
achronic
Quality
absolute
Basis
languages surveyed in Dixon 1995
Source
Dixon 1979: 92, Dixon 1995: 95
Counterexamples
Guajajara (Tupi): free forms cross-reference the nominative, bound forms are split, and often agree with the absolutive (Harrison 1986: 425).

One Comment

  1. FP
    FP

    1. Dixon gives two examples for this distribution: Murinypata (Daly, Australian) and Gahuku (Trans-New Guinea). 2. A. Harris 1997: 372 mentions one more example of this type: Udi (Lezgian, E. Caucasian) has case marking with ergative alignment and verb agreement with accusative alignment. She adds: “… it is not very likely that Dixon could have been aware of [this example] in forming his generalization”.

    1. May 2020

Comments are closed.