Skip to content

Universal 55: VSO ⇒ prepositions

Posted in Universals Archive

Universal 55: VSO ⇒ prepositions

Original
Languages with dominant VSO order are always prepositional.
Standardized
IF basic order is VSO, THEN adpositions precede their NPs (i.e. they are prepositions).
Keywords
order, VSO, preposition
Domain
syntax
Type
implication
Status
achronic
Quality
absolute (for Greenberg), statistical (for Dryer)
Basis
sample of 30 languages in Greenberg 1963; sample of 434 languages in Dryer 1992
Source
Greenberg 1963: 78, #3; Dryer 1992: 83
Counterexamples
Papago (Tepiman, Uto-Aztecan) (Greenberg 1963: 107, add. note)[but see Comment 3]; Cora (Corachol, Uto-Aztecan) and Tepehuán (Tepiman, Uto-Aztecan) are both VSO but have postpositions; Tetelcingo Aztec (Uto-Aztecan) [but see Comment 4], also VSO, has both prepositions and postpositions (Pickett 1983: 539).Iñapari (Arawak): verb-initial, postpositions; other properties: head-marking, polysynthetic, split-ergative cross-referencing (Parker 1995, reviewed by Aikhenvald 1998).Yagua (Peba-Yaguan): verb-initial, postpositions; other properties: Gen N, N A (Payne 1986). Guajajara (Tupi-Guaraní): verb initial, postpositions; other properties: Gen N, N A (Harrison 1983, 1986).Nomatsiguenga (Arawak): verb-initial, postpositions; other properties: N Gen, N A & A N (Payne 1986: 458, Wise 1971).Majang (Surma, Nilo-Saharan): verb-initial and postpositions (Dryer 1997: 132).Old Egyptian (Afro-Asiatic): VSO and Topic V (Agr) O, prepositions, but also two postpositions (-js ‘like’, -jsT ‘and’) that have been interpreted as relics of Afro-Asiatic case affixes (for details see Zeidler1992: 213-214)(F. Kammerzell, p.c.).Quileute (Chimakuan): verb-initial, postpositions (Payne 1990: 13) [but see Comment 5].

One Comment

  1. FP
    FP

    1. Andersen 1979 has argued that the existence and subsequent usage of prepositions or postpositions is not dependent upon the order of verb and object.On the other hand, Dryer 1992: 83 confirms Greenberg’s generalization on the basis of a 434-language sample.2. Cf. Rijkhoff’s claim (#448): If a language has verb-initial word order, then it has prepositions or case prefixes.3. Payne 1987 argues against classifying Papago as VSO. 4. Dryer 2000 classifies Tetelcingo Aztec as SVO.5. Dryer 2000 subsumes “postpositions” under case affixes. 6. Instead of an achronic implication this may be another diachronic one. To the extent that adpositions arise from verbs being grammaticalized, they would be expected to stay on the same side of their NP complements as they were in the source construction relative to their NP objects.

    1. May 2020

Comments are closed.